Why I Carry Three Notebooks (and Use All of Them for Something Different)

I own more notebooks than I will ever admit to out loud. Most of them have three pages written in the front and then nothing. A beautiful cover, a hopeful first entry, and then silence. For years I thought the problem was that I hadn't found the right one yet. Turns out the problem was that I was asking one notebook to do a job that actually needed three.

Here's the three-notebook system I landed on, and why splitting it up is the thing that finally made it stick.

The first one is for catching things, not solving them.

This one lives in my bag. It's small enough that I actually have it on me, which sounds obvious until you remember how many "everyday" journals get left on a nightstand. This is where I dump the raw material of a day. A line I overheard. A habit box I need to check off. A sentence that might become something later. Nothing in here has to be good. It just has to be caught before it disappears, because it always disappears if I wait.

The second one is where the actual building happens.

This is the notebook that comes out during the day, when I'm sitting down to do the work. Time logged, ideas scripted, the unglamorous back-and-forth of figuring something out on paper before it becomes a caption or a plan. If the first notebook is a butterfly net, this one is the workbench. Different tool, different posture, different part of the brain.

The third one is where the day gets put down.

At night, this is the one I write in before I let the day actually end. Not a highlight reel. A recap, one honest line about what actually happened, and one thing named for tomorrow so I'm not lying in bed trying to hold it all in my head. It's also, if I'm honest, where I finally finish the conversation I lost in real time eight hours earlier. I win every one of those. This is the notebook that closes the loop. Without it, everything from the first two notebooks just... accumulates. With it, there's an actual ending to the day, which is a smaller thing than it sounds like and also a bigger thing than it sounds like.

Here's what I got wrong for years: I kept trying to find one notebook that could catch, build, and close, all in the same set of pages. And it never worked, because those are three different jobs that want three different rhythms. Catching wants speed. Building wants space. Closing wants quiet. Asking one notebook to hold all three is like asking one drawer to be your junk drawer, your filing cabinet, and your medicine cabinet. Technically possible. Practically a mess.

Splitting it up didn't mean adding more to my day. It meant each notebook finally got small enough, and specific enough, to actually use. If you've got a stack of half-finished notebooks of your own (I see you), the fix isn't a fourth one that promises to be different. It's usually fewer jobs per notebook, not more notebooks.

If you're looking for something to start the "catch it before it disappears" notebook with, I use a Leuchtturm 1917 for exactly this. If you want something with a little more room to it, the Plannermonkey B6 Blue Freely Noted notebook is also in the shop and worth a look, Tomoe River paper, 416 pages, plenty of room to not be precious about which pages you use first.

The one thing I'd want you to take from this: you probably don't need a better notebook. You might need to stop asking one notebook to do three jobs at once.

Comment which of the three you're missing. I read all of them.

every day. on purpose. 🖊️

keep reading

Rest isn't the same as doing nothing, and I had to learn that the hard way
What Three Days Away Has Taught Me, Before I Even Know How It Ends

if this landed, the newsletter goes out every sunday with more of this. join here.